Skip to content
SecureElder

Comparing options

Home care vs. assisted living

A side-by-side look for Naperville-area families. Neither is better in general. The right choice depends on your parent's needs, wishes, and budget.

Side by side

Home careAssisted living
SettingYour parent's own homeAn apartment or room in a licensed community
Help includedOnly the help you schedule, such as bathing, meals, errands, and companionshipMeals, housekeeping, activities, and help with daily tasks, often by care level
Night supervisionOnly if you schedule overnight or live-in careStaff on site around the clock
Cost structureHourly, so cost rises with hours of helpMonthly rate plus care level fees

The questions that usually decide it

  • How many hours of help does your parent need each day, and at night?
  • Is the home safe and practical, with stairs, bathrooms, and access to help?
  • Is loneliness or isolation part of the problem?
  • How strongly does your parent want to stay at home?
  • How much can family realistically help, and for how long?
  • What does the budget look like for each option over a year or more?

With few hours of help needed, home care is often less expensive. As hours grow, especially toward round-the-clock care, the cost of home care can exceed a monthly community rate. See home care costs and senior living costs to compare.

Your next step

Not sure what level of help fits? Answer a few short questions to get a plain-language starting point. It takes about two minutes.

Take the level of care quiz